Welcome to Mighty Auto Sales

Neenah's best choice for quality used cars

Our knowledgeable sales representatives are committed to providing you with a "no-pressure" buying experience. We want to make sure you find the vehicle that meets your needs and fits your budget.

Our inventory specializes in personal off lease and local franchise dealer trade-ins in the Neenah, WI area.

Please feel free to browse our site and review our current inventory.


Over  25,000 vehicles sold to date!

Read Our Reviews

Our goal is always 100% satisfaction. See what some of our previous customers had to say about their car buying experience!

Jun 02, 2020

Michael Mandujano

Good experience. As of right now great place to buy a used car (will update in the next weeks if needed) We came to Mighty Auto from just outside of the Milwaukee area because of the prices we saw advertised. I was worried that they might be too go to be true. When we got there we learned there was no game or scheme with the advertised price. The prices Mighty offers are very competitive and we ended up buying a car that had a sticker price below blue-book value. The only thing to know is that they will stick their advertised price and go no lower. Overall a great experience where you do not have to haggle with a car dealer.

May 31, 2020

Tyler Doucette

If you’re anything like me trying to find a new vehicle is one of the most stressful things you can go through. The staff at mighty auto we’re very easy to work with. Didn’t pressure me into buying something I didn’t want. They were only concerned with finding me the right car for me and my family. Best experience I’ve ever had with a car dealership.

May 28, 2020

Nicole Cavin

Very good experience! Came in looking for a car, left with my dream car and a piece of mind knowing that the staff was upfront and honest with me! I would recommend this place because the staff is insanely friendly and helpful and they work with you to get you the kind of car you want, no matter the circumstances. I am very happy I chose this dealership!

May 28, 2020

Mark Collins

What a great car dealership! After car shopping all day we stopped here. David and Cody were both very friendly and listened to what we wanted in a vehicle. The who process was fast and easy! They didn't drag the whole process out like the big dealerships do. I will definitely start at Mighty Auto next time I'm in the market for a new vehicle!

May 24, 2020

Natasha M

On our second vehicle from here and we love it. With our first purchase from them a few years ago we found a problem with a window switch and they were able to fix the issue for us. Very helpful team

May 20, 2020

Karen Fonti

These folks have great deals and professional yet very personable.

May 15, 2020

Ashley B.

My first dealership experience was when my boyfriend purchased from somewhere else and it was the most painful and awful thing. This was personally my first dealership experience and they were AMAZING! They were super patient with me while I tried out several vehicles and always had something to say. I really felt treated like their number 1 priority even though it was pretty busy. The financing aspect was great, too! I feel I got honest answers to my questions and lots of great info. Even the follow up (they had to order a part) was super fast...and even though the sale was done I never felt brushed off or unimportant. In some way I had contact with almost all the staff and everyone of them were always friendly and great to work with! Thank you!!

May 14, 2020

Zeola Owens

Bought a Jeep the other day !! Great experience friendly staff very patient with me and all the cars I chose to test drive. They did not push me at all to buy a vehicle and made suggestions to help with what I was looking for . Made the paper work so easy and explained and answered all questions I had . Will definitely recommend to friends and family . Great prices too .

May 14, 2020

Leah Keller

Entire staff was very friendly and welcoming. We got a great starting price plus a very fair trade-in. We weren’t badgered or rushed into a deal. Very responsive to our financing needs. Fixed a minor detailing item they had missed before we left the lot. Made sure we knew all our options and we felt like they did what they could to get us the best price and financing. Would definitely return!

May 09, 2020

Jordan Marchant

My wife and I started looking for a new to us vehicle for our growing family few weeks ago. We had browsed a few websites and took a test drive at another dealership, looking for a good fit for our family. And even with that searching, we weren't feeling convinced we were finding the best value. Thankfully, my wife was scrolling through some options online when she came to a vehicle at Mighty Auto and was really impressed. We then took a closer comparison online and we were pleasantly surprised with how positive things were looking. To our satisfaction, that experience was only to get better once we got in the vehicle. We found it in great condition, with a clean Carfax history, lower mileage than others like it in the area, and yet still about $2K less than anywhere else around for that same vehicle! In hindsight, I shouldn't have been surprised by this. Back in 2014, I had bought my Hyundai Sonata from Mighty. That car has been a dependable asset to me as I put on quite a few miles for work. Just short of 200K miles in the last 6 years to be exact, and the car looks and runs as good as it did back then. I am very impressed with our fair, friendly and common sense car buying experience at Mighty Auto and I would highly recommend you check them out for yourself!

May 06, 2020

Tracy Bolle

I had an awesome experience by the Toyota RAV4 you guys were awesome

Apr 29, 2020

Tammy Kons

Buying a new vehicle can be very stressful and the whole COVID situation adds to that. The crew at Mighty was quick to respond to my emails and set up my appointment right away. Everyone was very pleasant and easy to work with. The process was quick and everything went smoothly. I can’t thank them enough for all their help!

Apr 25, 2020

Jackie Hackel

Our experience with Mighty Auto Sales was very smooth! The staff was very helpful and accommodating??

Apr 24, 2020

Kayla Robinson

Everyone was great there. Super knowledgeable and helpful to find the right vehicle for me. I asked to test drive a couple different SUVs. I once even had a vehicle brought up to test drive then later I said sorry nevermind and they didnt care, they said no big deal, I'll pull up another. All were just super nice! I love my blue '17 Ford Escape SE!!! Financing was pain free. Brad was knowledgeable and helpful about warranties and gap coverage

Apr 23, 2020

Joe O

Needed to trade up for a newer vehicle, had great selection at a great price. Dave was nice and friendly with no pressure. I would recommend this place to anyone needing a vehicle. Staff was knowledgeable about all there cars, the lot was easy to find what your looking for.

Apr 18, 2020

Tim Wright

Just upgraded trucks from a 01 to a 05 F-150. Service was so helpful and convenient that it was almost as easy as going to the store for a gallon of milk. These guys are on it. Customer service, pricing and just an all around great experience. Hats off to Mighty !!!! If I ever need another used car, I will definitely look there first. Tim, New London.

Apr 15, 2020

Dawn Timm

We are very happy with our purchase at Mighty Auto! We got a great price on a low mileage, well maintained used suv. The guys in sales and finance were very helpful.

Apr 12, 2020

Ben Schissel

The salespeople at Mighty auto were able to help my girlfriend find the vehicle she wanted and helped her set up an affordable payment plan for her. Thank you to the salespeople and especially, to the sales manager!

Apr 12, 2020

Katie Hackl

Incredible selection, quality vehicles, friendly staff who went above and beyond to accommodate me and assist me in finding the perfect vehicle! Good place, good people. Highly recommend!

Mar 25, 2020

Brent Hoppe

Great over the phone service, easy credit app, service all the way through the process was excellent. Love the vehicle also.

Mar 10, 2020

April G

What a great experience! Thank you for making it possible to drive away the same day with our new car. Everyone was so friendly and knowledgeable and not to mention fun! Great job and great prices! I will be back for future purchases.

Mar 07, 2020

Lor Schwartz

Excellent service! Got the difficult deal done and I’m in a vehicle I love!! Justin is an excellent salesman and stands behind what he says. My son will be looking at cars to buy from him as well. Recommend 100 %. Thanks Justin and Jim

Mar 06, 2020

Kyrsten Van Pay

Awesome first time experience with Mighty Auto. I was super indecisive and they were so cool and nice about it. My salesman, Cody, was not pushy at all and talked me through pros and cons well to help me weigh my options. Him as well as the finance manager truly seemed like they cared that I get the car that is perfect for me. Would definitely recommend!

Mar 02, 2020

maggy lloyd

I got my new toyota yaris from here and i love it!! Great experience, and super nice people. They let me test drive as many vehicles as i wanted. Would highly recommend this place if you are looking for a newer used vehicle!

Feb 29, 2020

Shannon Beckman

Just helped my son finance his first car! The folks at Mighty Auto were fantastic to work with. Thank you for making our experience so positive! We definitely recommend them :).

Feb 26, 2020

Tiffany Cuccia

All the staff were extremely helpful, Even Gene, a mechanic that works there! My Highlander is a great truck. Thanks for the awesome experience!!

Feb 26, 2020

Brittany Benish

Mighty Auto was such an unexpected find and positive experience for me! They worked with my budget and even helped me find exactly what I was looking for while keeping me under budget after taxes! The workers there are very friendly and the atmosphere there is very positive. They were very honest and upfront with me and I could tell they were trying to get me the best deal possible to help me and not take advantage of my pocketbook. I HIGHLY recommend them! I’ve never had such a good experience with a dealership before them. Will definitely return if I need a car in the future!

Feb 22, 2020

Eric Combs

The team at Mighty Auto provided top-notch quality of care as a new patron. I partnered with Dave Jastrow. He personified courtesy and respect for my needs and catered to them with ease. It was an epic price considering the vehicle's features, quality, year of manufacture, and mileage. His teammates helped me find the best rate for financing. They also performed a superb job of describing all of the financing options. I would purchase again from Mighty Auto in a heartbeat. I have no complaints as I pulled away in my new Toyota RAV4!

Feb 10, 2020

Greg Lang

Just bought my second car from Mighty and will be back in the future. Nothing but professional guys to work with.

Feb 09, 2020

Joanne Ball

Awesome customer service, knowledgeable, good variety of vehicles, fair prices

Feb 05, 2020


Matt is the guy! Had issues an he fixed everything. Now we have a nice 2016 cx-5. Thanks guys

Feb 04, 2020

Breanna Swiertz

Just picked up my new (to me) used 2017 Hyundai Tucson from Mighty Auto in Neenah. I cannot say enough good things about my experience here. The owner, Matt, made me feel welcome the second I walked through the door. I gave him a small idea of what I was looking for and he pulled several SUV’s to the front of the store for me and kept them running so I would stay warm. The entire staff was patient and helpful as I test drove several different vehicles. Once I finally found the one I wanted, Dave took me through the next steps in the buying process and helped me get the paperwork filled out. Never once did I feel rushed or pressured into making a decision. When I arrived today to finish everything up and take the car home, it was clean, already running, and ready to go. I thought buying my first nice/newer car was going to be scary, but the staff at Mighty Auto made the process simple and stress free for me. I will definitely send everyone I know that is in search of a new car their way. THANK YOU!!

Dec 31, 2019

Barbara Bloomer

Thanks to Bob and everyone at Mighty for making buying my car so easy!

Dec 20, 2019

Noxious Karn

Was referred by a friend. I've got some bad credit but Trina was willing to work with me and walked me through the process. Within 24 hours of walking on the lot I drive home in an affordable reliable car and a great warranty. Edit: 12/18/2019 The Warranty has been a godsend folks make sure you fully understand what it can do for you. I bought a 2014 Chrysler 200 paid $2500 for the warranty and so far claims made and paid by the warranty have exceded its cost Warranty 2500 Claims 1400 for shocks within 3 months of ownership 4600 for a new transmission to be installed this week. Saved 3500 already and I still have 5 years and another 70k Miles left on the warranty as I drove it almost 60k miles since purchase i have another 65k miles til it expires Get the warranty talk to Brad about it he knows all the ins and outs of it. I cant stop telling people how awesome my experience with mighty has been for the entire time of our business relationship. Edit 2 just got off the phone with Brad yesterday and mighty is also giving me a loaner car while my vehicle is in for service at another repair facility if that doesn't tell you that mighty cares about their customers then I'm missing something then I'm missing something. Mighty is pretty good if you're looking for a car you should come here

Dec 18, 2019

Kevin Lehto

Dave was extremely helpful in finding us an SUV. It was snowing out and he warmed up the vehicles for us and was very knowledgeable. We liked the one shop pricing so we knew what we were paying for the vehicle. He recommended a vehicle that was not on our list (2017 Hyundai) and we ended up buying it. This is our fourth vehicle from Mighty auto. I would recommend them to everyone.

Dec 13, 2019

Christopher Janssen

This was my first purchase from Mighty Auto and I must say I will 110% be returning in the future. Cody and Brad were awesome and treated my family and I extremely well. The whole staff is incredible tbh. Completely in love with my car. Awesome job guys!! ??

Dec 13, 2019

Mick Janssen

Over the years our family has purchased 4 vehicles from Mighty Auto Sales. We have always received a great deal with no pressure whatsoever. Everyone we worked with from Cody the salesperson to Brad the finance manager treated us like family. I definitely recommend them and will buy from them in the future.

Dec 11, 2019

Maynard Miller

They're absolutely the best dealership out there

Nov 10, 2019

Alex Faust

I was in situation where I needed a car quickly, and Mighty Auto Sales rose to the occasion. From initial correspondence all the way to the final sale, the staff at Mighty were excellent to work with.

Nov 10, 2019

Nicholas Scherer

Such helpful associates. Thank you for our new car.

Nov 07, 2019

Toy Train

Thank goodness for up front pricing. I was so sick of the sales person and manager theatrics in the past. Buying a car from Mighty was a breeze. Best price in the state.

Oct 30, 2019

Eric Prestay

Had a great experience buying my truck through this dealership. My salesman was very easy going and knew the vehicles history. He helped me throughout the buying process, along with talking to the other salesman to finalize the steps before and after the purchase. I highly recommend Mighty Auto.

Oct 29, 2019

Ed Eilert

Had a very good experience, friendly, helpful and answered my questions. Had to wait a bit to close the deal, they were busy. They had the vehicle I was looking for and got it ready to go in a day. Thanks!

Oct 20, 2019

Mary Robinson

They were awesome to work with, no pressure at all. Would definitely recommend!

Oct 14, 2019

Laura Mikkelson

The people at Mighty were very helpful, knowledgeable, and personable! They made purchasing a vehicle awesome! We will definitely go back to them when we need another vehicle!!

Oct 11, 2019

Charlotte Hecht

After searching for the "right"vehicle for 9 months, we found our new SUV! We recieved prompt courteous service. Our concerns were addressed and we were completely satisfied with the staff.

Oct 09, 2019

Peter Liethen

A great buying experience!!

Oct 08, 2019

John Krueger

Recently purchased a 2013 Honda Pilot from Mighty Auto Sales. This was the second car our family has purchased from Mighty Auto. Staff was friendly, courteous, and professional. I was very satisfied with my experience.

Sep 27, 2019

Chris Shook

The guys were great to my nephew. He's over the moon happy with his new car and he got a good deal on it to boot.

Sep 27, 2019

Mykal Noah

Just bought a 2016 Subaru Crosstrek I traded in my car and they were willing to meet me in the middle for how much my trade-in was worth Exellent.